Australia: ‘Medical apartheid’: Fair Work deputy calls forced vaccination coercive and punitive

Indigenous children should be focus for country-wide COVID-19 vaccination drive, Aboriginal health experts say

  Indigenous children should be focus for country-wide COVID-19 vaccination drive, Aboriginal health experts say First Nations children are now a focus for ramping up vaccination rates, as vulnerable families continue to become infected with COVID-19.The 13-year-old was unable to be vaccinated and caught COVID-19 at school.

Very few people are willing to say they are anti-vaccination per se, although there’s no law or moral code against being so. Vaccination is just a tool of public health. You can object to bike helmets because they mess up your hair, but being part of a society includes accepting that if the law says you have to wear one for the greater good, you do.

  ‘Medical apartheid’: Fair Work deputy calls forced vaccination coercive and punitive © Provided by Crikey

Vaccination is a harder question because it is medically intrusive. However, there’s no universally recognised human right that overrides the social principle that may dictate vaccination if that’s what is necessary.

Necessity is where we’re getting tangled on COVID vaccination, because we simply don’t know if it’s necessary or not.  Unfortunately we’re not having the conversation that would provide a clear answer, which is essentially a pragmatic one based on the best available science. Instead we have opposed views which call on incompatible rights (my right to not get COVID, your right to not get vaccinated).

Annastacia Palaszczuk said the Doherty modelling predicted 80 deaths a day and 2,240 a month after six months. Is that correct?

  Annastacia Palaszczuk said the Doherty modelling predicted 80 deaths a day and 2,240 a month after six months. Is that correct? Queensland Premier Annastacia Palaszczuk said the Doherty modelling predicted 80 deaths a day in Australia after six months, and 2,240 per month. Is that correct? RMIT ABC Fact Check investigates. The verdictMs Palaszczuk's claim is misleading.The outcome the Premier selected refers to a graph in the modelling report, which contains the results of just one of the scenarios modelled by the Doherty Institute.The graph contains a range of modelled outcomes for daily deaths over six months.Ms Palaszczuk has chosen an extreme outcome, which shows 80 daily deaths at the end of the six months.

That way lies disaster, as exemplified by Jennifer Kimber and the Fair Work Commission. Kimber, a receptionist at an aged care facility in New South Wales, refused to get an influenza vaccine when that became mandatory for aged care workers last year, and was sacked.

  ‘Medical apartheid’: Fair Work deputy calls forced vaccination coercive and punitive © Provided by Crikey

How to convince an anti-vaxxer: let businesses reward vaccinated customers

Read More

The FWC upheld that outcome, but deputy president Lyndall Dean dissented. The case did not involve COVID vaccination, except to the minor extent that Kimber had also belatedly indicated she might not want to get that either, reinforcing the opinion of the FWC majority that she actually “holds a general anti-vaccination position”. And making her reinstatement pointless, because COVID vaccination is now also mandatory for aged care workers.

People in their 20s and 30s push NSW closer to reopening

  People in their 20s and 30s push NSW closer to reopening In the week ending Tuesday, roughly one in 10 people aged between 16 and 39 in the state completed their vaccination against COVID-19, federal data shows.People in their 20s and 30s are pushing NSW closer to reopening as they come forward for second doses of the COVID-19 vaccine in droves.

Although the case wasn’t about COVID, Dean decided this was as good an opportunity as she was going to get to write 84 paragraphs into her dissenting decision about what she described as “the introduction of a system of medical apartheid and segregation in Australia”. And she went for it.

Dean is not anti-vax, apparently, but she sure isn’t pro-vax either. Her concerns are couched in the language of human rights (such as article 7 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, which provides that “no one shall be subjected without his free consent to medical or scientific experimentation”).

Whoa. Experimentation? Yes, because the Therapeutic Goods Administration has only ever given provisional approval to the COVID vaccines, which means by definition that they are still experimental and WE ARE ALL PARTICIPATING IN A CLINICAL TRIAL (OK, she didn’t capitalise that bit but it does jump off the page).

Fair Work official lashes mandatory jabs

  Fair Work official lashes mandatory jabs A Fair Work Commission deputy president has defended a sacked aged care worker, who refused to have a flu jab, in a stinging criticism of mandatory vaccination.Aged care receptionist Jennifer Kimber was sacked from a NSW south coast nursing home in July last year after refusing to have a flu jab.

To underline which territory we’re in here, there’s a reference to the “Nuremburg code, formulated in 1947 in response to Nazi doctors performing medical experiments on people during WWII”.

Next: can employers mandate COVID vaccination on workplace health and safety grounds? No. Why? Because the only risk is from people who have COVID:

There is no risk associated with a person who is unvaccinated and does not have COVID …

Employers who mandate vaccinations will be liable for any adverse reactions their workers may experience, given this is a foreseeable outcome for some people.

As for the legal validity of the public health orders, made by state government ministers under legislation, again no:

[Public health orders] cannot lawfully be used in a way that is punitive, and human rights are not suspended during states of emergency or disaster. The current PHOs have moved well past the minimum necessary to achieve public health aims, and into the realm of depravation.

Her word, not mine. Depravation: the state of being depraved or degenerated.

Strictly faces calls to increase testing

  Strictly faces calls to increase testing The duo confirmed on Sunday that they were in isolation after testing positive, and there are now concerns around whether they could have spread the virus to other stars. While it's unclear whether bosses plan to heighten their already-stringent Covid measures, the news has faced backlash from some fans who claimed Tom and Amy have been given a 'free pass' to avoid the first elimination.

That the governments have gone too far is illustrated by references to the 17,385 people who died in Australia with influenza or pneumonia in 2019 (footnote: only 600 or so died of those diseases); and in the same year, there were 4344 paedophiles on the NSW child protection register who don’t “have to declare that they are paedophiles before entering a business”.

  ‘Medical apartheid’: Fair Work deputy calls forced vaccination coercive and punitive © Provided by Crikey

‘We mustn’t let anti-vaxxers turn us into conspiracy theorists’

Read More

Also: anyone who dismisses an employee or refuses entry on the basis of COVID non-vaccination will breach the Disability Discrimination Act. Quoting as her reference an article in The Spectator by a retired solicitor, Dean repeats an entirely incorrect interpretation of that law to support her case.

Her final comments are epic. Vaccination mandates “are not measures to protect public health” and “do not address the actual risk of COVID. These measures can only be about punishing those who choose not to be vaccinated. If the purpose of the PHOs is genuinely to reduce the spread of COVID, there is no basis for locking out people who do not have COVID, which is easily established by a rapid antigen test.”

Well, not quite. According to the Royal Australian College of General Practitioners, studies have shown a correct positive rate of 40% to 74% in people without symptoms, meaning a pretty substantial proportion of false negatives are likely with rapid antigen tests.

Not that Dean is necessarily wrong about her concerns (apart from the disability discrimination part), although her excursion through most of the tropes of the anti-vax school don’t help her cause in my view.

The problem is that the refusal by governments to address the practical question of mandatory vaccination and legislate the solution (whatever that is) continues to leave the field wide open to crackpots and enthusiasts — and to a judicial officer who has been itching to lay out her thesis, despite its irrelevance to the question she was commissioned to answer.

Random think-pieces and arbitrary decisions are no way to address the biggest public health question in our history.

The post ‘Medical apartheid’: Fair Work deputy calls forced vaccination coercive and punitive appeared first on Crikey.

Dominic Perrottet reveals HUGE changes to NSW roadmap out of lockdown .
NSW Premier Dominic Perrottet has unveiled major changes to the state's roadmap - including allowing all school students to return to the classroom by October 25.Mr Perrottet said Kindergarten, Year 1 and Year 12 would now return to school on Monday October 18, with students in all year groups back on-site by October 25.

See also