World: WhatsApp: We won't lower security for any government

Premier League 'close to agreeing new system to support lower leagues'

  Premier League 'close to agreeing new system to support lower leagues' The Premier League is reportedly closer to agreeing a new financial system to support clubs in the lower leagues. It would change how cash is distributed to those in the lower leagues.As reported by the Times , the 20 sides that make up the top flight discussed a plan titled 'A New Deal for Football' at a shareholders' meeting in London on Tuesday.

The boss of WhatsApp says it will not "lower the security" of its messenger service.

  WhatsApp: We won't lower security for any government © Getty Images

If asked by the government to weaken encryption, it would be "very foolish" to accept, Will Cathcart told the BBC.

Government plans to detect child sex-abuse images include the possible scanning of private messages.

The NSPCC has criticised WhatsApp's position, saying that direct messaging is "the front line" of child sexual abuse.

The government says tech firms need to tackle child-abuse material online. Its proposals are part of the Online Safety Bill, which has been delayed until the autumn.

"They shouldn't ignore the clear risk that end-to-end encryption could blind them to this content and hamper efforts to catch the perpetrators," said a government spokesperson.

Nigeria’s fragile security architecture is collapsing

  Nigeria’s fragile security architecture is collapsing The government needs to take swift action to prevent further security failures similar to those experienced on June 5.Late on July 5, heavily armed men on motorcycles raided the Kuje Medium Security Custodial Centre on the outskirts of Abuja and released more than 900 inmates, including more than 60 Boko Haram members in detention. The Islamic State West Africa Province (ISWAP) – an offshoot of Boko Haram now allied with the ISIL (ISIS) group – claimed responsibility for the attack.

"We continue to work with the tech sector to support the development of innovative technologies that protect public safety without compromising on privacy."

  WhatsApp: We won't lower security for any government © Getty Images

End-to-end encryption (E2EE) provides the most robust level of security, because - by design - only the intended recipient holds the key to decrypt the message, which is essential for private communication.

The technology underpins the online exchanges on apps including WhatsApp, Signal, Telegram and - optionally - on Facebook messenger.

Only the sender and receiver can read those messages - not law enforcement or the technology giants.

The conundrum currently facing the technology community is the UK government's pledge to support the development of tools which could detect illegal pictures within or around an E2EE environment, while respecting user privacy.

Watchdog singles out ACT court for 'extremely unusual' decision in secret trial of former military intelligence officer that 'should not have happened'

  Watchdog singles out ACT court for 'extremely unusual' decision in secret trial of former military intelligence officer that 'should not have happened' The top-secret trial, conviction, sentencing and jailing of a former military intelligence officer known as Witness J has been described as "unusual" and "unprecedented", with one of Australia's national security watchdogs warning it "should never happen again".The man, referred to as Witness J or Alan Johns, was convicted of mishandling classified information that, potentially, revealed the identities of agents recruited by Australian intelligence agencies.

Experts have questioned whether it is possible to achieve - and most conclude client-side scanning is the only tangible option. But this destroys the fundamentals of E2EE, as messages would no longer be private.

'Business decision'

"Client-side scanning cannot work in practice," Mr Cathcart said.

Because millions of people use WhatsApp to communicate across the world, it needs to maintain the same standards of privacy across every country, he added.

"If we had to lower security for the world, to accommodate the requirement in one country, that...would be very foolish for us to accept, making our product less desirable to 98% of our users because of the requirements from 2%," Mr Cathcart told BBC News.

The EU Commission has said technology companies should "detect, report, block and remove" child sex abuse images from their platforms.

"What's being proposed is that we - either directly or indirectly through software - read everyone's messages," Mr Cathcart said. "I don't think people want that."

Adriana Benhamou Weiss sent Whatsapp message asking junior worker to Photoshop payment confirmations

  Adriana Benhamou Weiss sent Whatsapp message asking junior worker to Photoshop payment confirmations Adriana Benhamou Weiss decorated the mansions of Australian multi-millionaires, designed hotels and apartment developments in Paris, Moscow, and the French Riviera.Adriana Benhamou Weiss decorated the mansions of Australian multi-millionaires and designed hotels and apartment developments in Paris, Moscow, the French Riviera as well as luxury properties in Israel and the Middle East.

'Mass surveillance'

The UK and EU plans echo Apple's effort, last year, to scan photographs on people's iPhones for abusive content before it was uploaded to iCloud. But Apple rolled back the plans after privacy groups claimed the technology giant had created a security backdoor in its software.

Ella Jakubowska, policy adviser at campaign group European Digital Rights, said: "Client-side scanning is almost like putting spyware on every person's phone.

"It also creates a backdoor for malicious actors to have a way in to be able to see your messages."

Dr Monica Horten, policy manager for the campaign organisation Open Rights Group, agreed: "If Apple can't get it right, how can the government?

"Client-side scanning is a form of mass surveillance - it is a deep interference with privacy."

Prof Alan Woodward, of the University of Surrey, told BBC News that scanning could be misused: "Of course, if you say: 'Do you think children should be kept safe?' everyone's going to say 'yes'.

"But if you then say to someone: 'Right, I'm going to put something on your phone that's going to scan every single one of your images and compare it against the database,' then suddenly you start to realise the implications."

Wayne Rooney flew back from US to celebrate Coleen's Wagatha Christie victory over Rebekah Vardy

  Wayne Rooney flew back from US to celebrate Coleen's Wagatha Christie victory over Rebekah Vardy Wayne Rooney was in Washington managing DC United when the ruling came in yesterday and flew back to celebrate the victory with his family by visiting his favourite Chinese restaurantThe former England star was in Washington DC, where he now manages DC United, but flew back for the ruling which found yesterday that his wife had won the high-profile libel case over Rebekah Vardy.

'Very effective'

Mr Cathcart said WhatsApp already detected hundreds of thousands of child sex-abuse images.

"There are techniques that are very effective and that have not been adopted by the industry and do not require us sacrificing everyone's security," he said. "We report more than almost any other internet service in the world."

But that claim has angered children's charities.

  WhatsApp: We won't lower security for any government © Getty Images

'Front line'

"The reality is that as it stands right now, under this cloak of encryption, they are identifying only a fraction of the levels of abuse that the sister products, Facebook and Instagram, are able to detect," NSPCC head of child safety online policy, Andy Burrows said.

He called direct messaging "the front line" of child sexual abuse.

"Two-thirds of child abuse that is currently identified and taken down is seen and removed in private messaging," Mr Burrows told BBC News.

"It's increasingly clear that it doesn't have to be children's safety and adult privacy that are pitted against each other. We want a discussion about what a balanced settlement can look like."

For the full debate, you can listen to 'The battle over encrypted messaging' on Tech Tent on BBC Sounds.

Follow Shiona McCallum on Twitter @shionamc.

Albanese government passes climate bill through the lower house .
The bill passed through the House of Representatives 89 votes to 55. READ MORE: Five states bracing for destructive storm © AP The Albanese government has passed its climate bill through the lower house. "I am very pleased that the climate legislation has passed the House of Representatives," Prime Minister Anthony Albanese said. "This is a fulfilment of a core promise that we made at the election of a 43 per cent reduction in emissions by 2030 and a renewable sector that will grow to 82 per cent of our national energy market by 2030.

See also