Travel: Want to earn Loyalty Points? Here’s why booking through American Airlines Vacations isn’t always best

How to earn bonus miles through the AAdvantage shopping portal

  How to earn bonus miles through the AAdvantage shopping portal Online shopping portals are one of the easiest ways to boost your rewards balances. These programs offer bonus points for various airline and hotel programs just for shopping online through the portals. For such an effortless way to earn points, it would be a mistake not to utilize them. In this guide we’re going to …In this guide we’re going to talk about how to use the American Airlines AAdvantage eShopping portal. If you play your cards right, this could be a lucrative tactic that could lead to an award flight sooner than you may have thought. Domestic award bookings start as low as 5,000 AAdvantage miles, but sometimes you can score an even better deal through an AA Web Special.

MSN has partnered with The Points Guy for our coverage of credit card products. MSN and The Points Guy may receive a commission from card issuers.

With Loyalty Points as the new way of earning American Airlines elite status, TPG wanted to test out how various ways of earning American Airlines miles would post.

So, when I saw an American Airlines Vacations promotion offering 20,000 bonus miles at select AMResorts properties in the Dominican Republic earlier this year, I booked.

I was hopeful that the 20,000 miles would be Loyalty Points-eligible. But, although the 1,000 bonus miles for booking online through American Airlines Vacations ended up being Loyalty Points-eligible, the 20,000 bonus miles from the promotion didn’t post as Loyalty Points.

Sweet Spot Sunday: Fly from the US to Australia with a stop in Fiji for 20k miles plus $92

  Sweet Spot Sunday: Fly from the US to Australia with a stop in Fiji for 20k miles plus $92 Editor’s note: This post has been updated with current information. Now that Australia has reopened to U.S. tourists, many travelers are more excited than ever about booking a trip Down Under. What’s better than a trip to Australia? Visiting Australia and Fiji on the same trip. Plus, stopping in Fiji when flying between the U.S. …Now that Australia has reopened to U.S. tourists, many travelers are more excited than ever about booking a trip Down Under. What’s better than a trip to Australia? Visiting Australia and Fiji on the same trip. Plus, stopping in Fiji when flying between the U.S. and Australia lets you break up your trans-Pacific journey.

Twenty thousand AAdvantage miles are worth $354 based on TPG’s valuations. So, due to the bonus miles, booking through American Airlines Vacations may have still been the “right” choice for me.

But my experience highlights something that might not be widely known: Booking through American Airlines Vacations often won’t be the best way to book if you want to earn Loyalty Points.

Let’s take a closer look at my trip and when you should and shouldn’t use American Airlines Vacations if your primary goal is earning Loyalty Points.

Sign up for our daily newsletter for more TPG news delivered each morning to your inbox.

In This Post

A closer look at my American Airlines Vacations trip

I booked round-trip flights from New York to Punta Cana, a five-night stay at Dreams Palm Beach Punta Cana and round-trip airport transportation in the Dominican Republic for $2,059 through American Airlines Vacations.

Your ultimate guide to American Airlines AAdvantage

  Your ultimate guide to American Airlines AAdvantage American Airlines AAdvantage miles have been devalued over the last few years, but you can still get a ton of value out of the program. And now might be the time to do so. American has made several consumer-friendly changes in recent months, including extending elite status for AAdvantage members, eliminating most change fees and …And now might be the time to do so. American has made several consumer-friendly changes in recent months, including extending elite status for AAdvantage members, eliminating most change fees and pausing mileage expiration. That’s on top of major changes like simplifying the AAdvantage elite status program and adding six months to the mileage expiration policy.

(Screenshot from aavacations.com) © The Points Guy (Screenshot from aavacations.com)

Based on the promotion’s terms, I needed to stay at an eligible AMResorts property for at least five nights and spend at least $2,000.

If I’d booked the least-expensive room type without airport transportation, my trip would have cost $1,790. But, to bump the cost over $2,000 and get the 20,000 bonus miles, I booked an upgraded room type. Specifically, I paid $49 more per night to get a Premium Tropical View room with Preferred Club access.

(Screenshot from aavacations.com) © The Points Guy (Screenshot from aavacations.com)

As the star next to the fare class on the above American Airlines Vacations itinerary indicates, my flights earned miles and Loyalty Points based on American Airlines’ special fares chart. After all, when booking a vacations package, you aren’t supposed to know exactly how much each element costs.

My nonstop flights between New York and Punta Cana were booked into fare class O. Based on American’s special fares chart, O fares earn 25% of the distance flown. These flights were 1,554 miles each way, so I earned 778 base miles on the round-trip flights. Plus, since I’m an Executive Platinum elite member, I earned 934 bonus miles for a total of 1,712 Loyalty Points-eligible miles.

AA miles begin expiring again at the end of this month — here’s how to keep them alive

  AA miles begin expiring again at the end of this month — here’s how to keep them alive Editor’s note: This article was originally published on Dec. 1, 2021, when AAdvantage miles were set to begin expiring on Dec. 31, 2021. It has since been updated to reflect the new expiration start date of April 1, 2022. It’s almost unbelievable that airline miles (or hotel points, for that matter) still have expiration dates. …It’s almost unbelievable that airline miles (or hotel points, for that matter) still have expiration dates. It’s like saying that a dollar bill in your pocket can only be used for a year or two after you earn it. Still, many airlines enforce expiration terms on their frequent flyer miles, and one of the largest to do so is American Airlines.

(Screenshot from aa.com) © The Points Guy (Screenshot from aa.com)

I also earned 1,000 bonus miles for booking online and the 20,000 bonus miles for booking an eligible stay at a participating AMResorts property. But, although the 1,000 miles for booking online were Loyalty Points-eligible, the 20,000 bonus miles weren’t.

In total, I earned 22,712 AAdvantage miles, 4,118 Capital One miles and 2,712 Loyalty Points on my $2,059 package. Based on TPG’s valuations, the AAdvantage miles I earned are worth $402 and the Capital One miles I earned by using the Capital One Venture X Rewards Credit Card to pay for my stay are worth $76.

So yes, the rewards I earned through booking this American Airlines Vacation are valuable. But I could have earned more Loyalty Points if I’d booked via other means. And the miles earned through American Airlines Vacations often won’t be nearly as compelling when there’s not a large bonus on the table.

Related: Chasing American Airlines elite status? Here are 14 ways to earn Loyalty Points


Gallery: 13 Insider Secrets From Travel Agents That Will Save You Money (GOBankingRates)

The best ways to use airline miles to fly to a reopening Vietnam

  The best ways to use airline miles to fly to a reopening Vietnam From the beaches of Nha Trang to the majestic waters of Ha Long Bay, Vietnam offers something for everyone. The country is reopening to vaccinated tourists on March 15, and many American travelers are itching to book their first trip. Fortunately, there are plenty of options for flying to Vietnam from the United States. Nonstop …The country is reopening to vaccinated tourists on March 15, and many American travelers are itching to book their first trip. Fortunately, there are plenty of options for flying to Vietnam from the United States.

Cute baby and mother walking outdoor travel family vacations lifestyle mom and smiling child together Mothers day holiday.

How I could have earned more Loyalty Points

Dreams Palm Beach Punta Cana. (Photo by Katie Genter/The Points Guy) © The Points Guy Dreams Palm Beach Punta Cana. (Photo by Katie Genter/The Points Guy)

I need Loyalty Points more than miles if I’m going to requalify for American Airlines Executive Platinum status. So, it might have been better to book my five-night trip to Punta Cana differently if my primary goal was to earn Loyalty Points.

For example, if I’d booked round-trip flights directly with American Airlines (instead of American Airlines Vacations), I would have earned Loyalty Points-eligible miles based on the fare. If I’d booked a $267 round trip (before taxes and fees), I would have earned 2,937 Loyalty Points-eligible miles as an Executive Platinum elite member. Or, if my flights were $400 (before taxes and fees), I would have earned 4,400 Loyalty Points-eligible miles.

Terrific tiny countries that are delightful destinations

  Terrific tiny countries that are delightful destinations If you’re feeling jittery about re-entering the world of international travel it might be an idea to avoid the world’s most popular (and populous) destinations. Instead venture to countries with the smallest populations and where crowds are rarely a problem. Thankfully, many of the world's least populous countries are also easy on the eye. From far-flung coral atolls and splendidly sleepy archipelagos to isolated mountainous republics, we have found some crowd-free countries that are perfect for a relaxing holiday.

To come out ahead on the round trip from New York to Punta Cana using special fares, my round-trip flights in O fare class would have needed to cost $155 or less (before taxes and fees). Of course, as I’ll discuss in the next section, you can sometimes come out ahead when booking special fares through American Airlines Vacations.

Testing whether you earn elite night credits when earning airline miles for hotel stays

  Testing whether you earn elite night credits when earning airline miles for hotel stays American Airlines is completely changing how you earn elite status. While the AAdvantage program is here to stay, you can say goodbye to the elite qualifying metrics of yore. Welcome to the world of Loyalty Points. It’s one of the biggest, ongoing stories in the industry, even though the program won’t officially launch until March. …Welcome to the world of Loyalty Points. It’s one of the biggest, ongoing stories in the industry, even though the program won’t officially launch until March. That’s because you can now get a head start and begin earning Loyalty Points that will count toward the 2023 status year (although points won’t be posted until March).

I also could have possibly earned more Loyalty Points-eligible miles if I’d booked my hotel differently. You typically won’t earn maximum American Loyalty Points when you book hotels directly. But you can often get a sizable amount of Loyalty Points-eligible miles when you book through Rocketmiles or American Airlines Hotels. For example, you could earn up to 46,000 miles on this sample five-night stay in Punta Cana this summer:

Why I’m not doing anything differently to earn American Airlines elite status

  Why I’m not doing anything differently to earn American Airlines elite status Some people might call me crazy, but I’m not going out of my way to earn American Airlines status right now. That’s not to say that I won’t end up requalifying for American’s Executive Platinum status at some point this year. But, I’m not changing my behavior to get there — at least for now. …That’s not to say that I won’t end up requalifying for American’s Executive Platinum status at some point this year. But, I’m not changing my behavior to get there — at least for now.

(Screenshot from rocketmiles.com) © The Points Guy (Screenshot from rocketmiles.com)

Or, you could earn 7,000 base miles on this sample one-night stay in Punta Cana:

(Screenshot from bookaahotels.com) © The Points Guy (Screenshot from bookaahotels.com)

Of course, it’s important to remember that you won’t get elite benefits or earnings on hotels when you book through Rocketmiles, American Airlines Vacations or American Airlines Hotels. But, if you have Hyatt elite status, you might want to link your Hyatt and American accounts and book directly with Hyatt.

Related: We tested earning American Airlines miles for 3 different hotel stays — here’s what we found

When and why you might want to book through American Airlines Vacations

Dreams Palm Beach Punta Cana. (Photo by Katie Genter/The Points Guy) © The Points Guy Dreams Palm Beach Punta Cana. (Photo by Katie Genter/The Points Guy)

Based on this article so far, you might assume you should never use American Airlines Vacations if you want to earn maximum Loyalty Points. But that’s not the case at all.

After all, the special fares you’ll sometimes get when booking through American Airlines Vacations can be lucrative for some trips. In particular, special fares can be lucrative on inexpensive but long flights in select fare classes.

To tell whether a trip bookable through American Airlines Vacations will earn miles (and hence Loyalty Points) based on the flight’s fare or the special fares chart, look for a star next to the fare class on the summary page before booking.

Let’s look at one example where it would make sense to book through American Airlines Vacations.

Consider this three-night premium cabin trip to Bogota, Colombia, for $716. This trip would use special fares, as you can see by the star next to “Mixed Cabin” (when you click “Flight Details,” you’ll see each flight is booked into fare class I).

(Screenshot from aavacations.com) © The Points Guy (Screenshot from aavacations.com)

The flight distance from New York to Miami is 1,089 miles each way and the flight distance from Miami to Bogota is 1,507 miles each way. I fares earn 100% of the distance flown but don’t get a cabin bonus.

So I’d earn about 6,192 Loyalty Points-eligible miles (including the 1,000 miles for booking online) if I booked through American Airlines Vacations. Plus, I’d get around 6,230 extra Loyalty Points-eligible miles as an Executive Platinum elite member, for a total of approximately 12,422 Loyalty Points-eligible miles.

Meanwhile, these flights would be $627 if booked separately. And as the below screenshot shows, I’d only earn 5,368 Loyalty Points if I booked through American’s website instead of American Airlines Vacations.

(Screenshot from aa.com) © The Points Guy (Screenshot from aa.com)

As you can see, there are cases where booking special fares through American Airlines Vacations can help you earn significantly more Loyalty Points. Just make sure to do the math before you book American flights in the future so you can maximize your Loyalty Points-earning.

Related: How I plan to earn American Airlines Executive Platinum status with Loyalty Points

Bottom line

I had a hunch that the 20,000 bonus miles for booking an eligible American Airlines Vacations package wouldn’t be Loyalty Points-eligible. After all, the frequently asked questions page of American’s Loyalty Points website notes that “base miles earned from spending with Loyalty Point-qualifying partners” count toward Loyalty Points and that “Bonus miles earned from special promotions” won’t earn Loyalty Points.

But it’s confusing that the 1,000 miles for booking online are Loyalty Points-eligible despite being called “bonus miles” on the American Airlines Vacations website. This confusion — and AAdvantage’s poor communication with its loyalists about the new Loyalty Points program — is the main reason I didn’t initially make a requalification plan for American Airlines elite status.

Regardless of whether you agree with how AAdvantage classifies base and bonus miles for American Airlines Vacations, at least now we know exactly how these packages will earn Loyalty Points. And, as I discussed above, there’s still plenty of value to be found when booking some trips through American Airlines Vacations.

Featured photo of Dreams Palm Beach Punta Cana by Katie Genter/The Points Guy.

SPONSORED: With states reopening, enjoying a meal from a restaurant no longer just means curbside pickup.

And when you do spend on dining, you should use a credit card that will maximize your rewards and potentially even score special discounts. Thanks to temporary card bonuses and changes due to coronavirus, you may even be able to score a meal at your favorite restaurant for free.

These are the best credit cards for dining out, taking out, and ordering in to maximize every meal purchase.

--

Editorial Disclaimer: Opinions expressed here are the author’s alone, not those of any bank, credit card issuer, airlines or hotel chain, and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any of these entities.

Why I’m not doing anything differently to earn American Airlines elite status .
Some people might call me crazy, but I’m not going out of my way to earn American Airlines status right now. That’s not to say that I won’t end up requalifying for American’s Executive Platinum status at some point this year. But, I’m not changing my behavior to get there — at least for now. …That’s not to say that I won’t end up requalifying for American’s Executive Platinum status at some point this year. But, I’m not changing my behavior to get there — at least for now.

See also