TOP News

Politics: Supreme Court likely to rule that Biden student loan plan is illegal, experts say. Here's what that means for borrowers

Biden, family attend Christmas tree lighting on Nantucket

  Biden, family attend Christmas tree lighting on Nantucket NANTUCKET, Mass. (AP) — The Biden family's tradition of eating lunch, shopping and watching a Christmas tree lighting in downtown Nantucket on Friday became mostly about keeping the president's 2-year-old grandson from having a meltdown. There was President Joe Biden's daughter, Ashley, dancing and clapping with nephew Beau to “Jingle Bell Rock” to keep him entertained as they waited with the crowd that had gathered for the 48th annual tree lighting ceremony on Main St. © Provided by The Associated Press President Joe Biden walks with his grandson Beau Biden in Nantucket, Mass., Friday, Nov. 25, 2022.

  • The Supreme Court will decide whether or not the president's debt relief policy causes harm to the plaintiffs or is an overreach of executive authority.
  • Legal experts say the Supreme Court is likely to end the forgiveness plan, given its conservative majority.
  • Long before the president acted, Republicans had criticized student loan forgiveness as a handout to well-off college graduates. They also argued the president didn't have the power to forgive consumer debt on his own without authorization from Congress.
Student loan debt holders take part in a demonstration outside of the White House staff entrance to demand that President Biden cancel student loan debt. © Provided by CNBC Student loan debt holders take part in a demonstration outside of the White House staff entrance to demand that President Biden cancel student loan debt.

The fate of the Biden administration's sweeping student loan forgiveness plan now rests with the Supreme Court.

Saudi Arabia is now backpedaling, seeking to mend ties with Biden after Democrats fared better-than-expected in the midterms

  Saudi Arabia is now backpedaling, seeking to mend ties with Biden after Democrats fared better-than-expected in the midterms Saudi Arabia was accused of interfering in the US midterms to damage the Democrats, sparking a diplomatic spatBiden announced Wednesday that he would cancel $10,000 in student debt for borrowers making under $125,000 per year, and $20,000 in debt for students who received Pell Grants.

That may be bad news for borrowers, say legal and higher education experts.

"The court's conservatives have been very aggressive in striking down the decisions of Congress and the president," said Gregory Caldeira, a political science professor at Ohio State University. "I would not be surprised if the court invalidated the executive order."

Higher education expert Mark Kantrowitz agreed.

More from Personal Finance:

Tax 'refunds may be smaller in 2023,' warns IRS. Here's why

Remote work 'revolution' is here to stay, say labor economists

The fear of loss can cost investors big-time. Here's how

"The U.S. Supreme Court is more likely than not to block the president's student loan forgiveness plan," Kantrowitz said.

The highest court decided to take the case after the U.S. Department of Justice filed an emergency application asking the justices to lift the injunction on its forgiveness plan that had been issued by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 8th Circuit, in St. Louis, at the request of six GOP-led states.

Federal appeals court keeps Biden student loan forgiveness plan on pause in latest ruling

  Federal appeals court keeps Biden student loan forgiveness plan on pause in latest ruling The decision will likely be appealed to the Supreme Court, which is already considering another challenge to Biden's student loan forgiveness plan.The brief order from the New Orleans-based U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit let stand a lower court ruling that had blocked the program's implementation. In response to a barrage of lawsuits, the Biden administration had already extended a pause on student loan payments until as late as June 30, 2023.

The justices, who will decide whether or not the president's debt relief policy causes harm to the plaintiffs or is an overreach of executive authority, said they would hear oral arguments in February.

Ruling will settle 'for now' student loan challenges

In August, Preisdent Joe Biden announced that the U.S. Department of Education would deliver student loan forgiveness of up to $20,000 for tens of millions of Americans. The nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office estimates the plan will cost around $400 billion.

Long before the president acted, Republicans had criticized student loan forgiveness as a handout to well-off college graduates. They also argued the president didn't have the power to forgive consumer debt on his own without authorization from Congress.

Unsurprisingly, the legal challenges poured in. At least six lawsuits have been brought against the president's plan.

Conservative Judges, GOP In Congress Get Public’s Ire For Student Loan Limbo: Poll

  Conservative Judges, GOP In Congress Get Public’s Ire For Student Loan Limbo: Poll Conservative Judges, GOP In Congress Get Public’s Ire For Student Loan Limbo: Poll appeared first on Knewz.

The administration closed its portal where borrowers could apply for the relief last month, although 26 million people had already requested it.

"The benefit of the Supreme Court ruling is that it will settle, for now, all of the litigation related to the loan forgiveness," said Dan Urman, a law professor at Northeastern University.

Why the Supreme Court may block forgiveness

For a number of reasons, Urman predicts the Supreme Court will rule against Biden. He said the conservative justices believe government agencies exert too much authority and "violate the separation of powers." In addition, he said, the concept of loan forgiveness seems to run counter to their notions of individual responsibility.

Such a politically fueled decision, however, is likely to further damage the public's perception of the Supreme Court, Urman said.

"Striking down forgiveness will add to growing skepticism that the conservative justices vote for conservatives, and the liberal justices vote for liberals," Urman said. Just 25% of Americans have confidence in the highest court, a Gallup poll found over the summer.

China's cities are running out of money to pay huge COVID lockdown bills, report says

  China's cities are running out of money to pay huge COVID lockdown bills, report says China's local governments are spending much more than they are taking in, CNN reported, as they conduct mass testing and lockdowns.Data from China's Ministry of Finance reported by CNN showed that local governments in China spent considerably more than they brought in between January and October: to the tune of more than $1.65 trillion.

If the president's plan is blocked, he added, it will be "another example, along with abortion and guns, of the court taking positions that a majority of Americans oppose."

In a poll conducted by The Economist and YouGov in August, 51% of respondents said they support Biden's loan relief plan. Around 40% oppose the initiative.

"In the past, the Supreme Court usually ruled in line with public opinion," Urman said.

Arguments over the limit of presidential power

Beyond the popularity of its debt relief plan, the Biden administration insists that it's acting within the law, pointing out that the Heroes Act of 2003 grants the education secretary the authority to waive regulations related to student loans during national emergencies. The U.S. has been operating under an emergency declaration since March 2020.

However, lawyers for the GOP-led states argue that the administration should not be able to use the public health crisis to issue such a sweeping policy.

"The administration is once again invoking the COVID-19 pandemic to assert power far beyond anything Congress could have conceived," the lawyers wrote in a brief to the justices, pointing out that the highest court previously stopped the White House's nationwide ban on evictions.

Yet a group of borrower advocacy groups, in a recent brief to the U.S. Supreme Court, said student debt forgiveness was essential to the country's recovery from the pandemic.

The public health crisis exacerbated the financial difficulties for "borrowers who have, for decades, been at the mercy of a broken student loan system," they wrote.

Without cancellation, they warned, "working and middle-class borrowers are at substantial risk of default."

A conservative group that blocked student-loan forgiveness wants the Supreme Court to take it up as the second case on the matter, arguing that 'Congress never could have fathomed' Biden would cancel student debt using the law that he did .
SCOTUS already agreed to take on one lawsuit that blocked student-debt relief. Another group that filed a separate lawsuit wants the same treatment.On Wednesday, the Job Creators Network, a conservative group representing plaintiffs who sued Biden's debt relief in October, wrote in a legal filing that the Supreme Court should take up the case.

See also