Politics: Progressives fear compromise could jeopardize midterm hopes

Pelosi delays infrastructure vote: Progressives won't budge without Build Back Better

  Pelosi delays infrastructure vote: Progressives won't budge without Build Back Better Progressive Democrats demonstrate "effective collective power," refusing to vote on infrastructure bill alone Congressional Progressive Caucus members Rep. Cori Bush, D-Mo., and Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, D-N.Y., talk to reporters outside the U.S. Capitol on Sept. 30, 2021.

Progressives are fretting over the pared-back framework of Democrats' massive social policy and climate bill, warning that it won't be enough to motivate the party's liberal base ahead of the 2022 midterms.

Senate Budget Committee Chairman Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) gives an opening statement during a hearing to discuss President Biden's budget request for FY 2022 on Tuesday, June 8, 2020 . © Greg Nash Senate Budget Committee Chairman Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) gives an opening statement during a hearing to discuss President Biden's budget request for FY 2022 on Tuesday, June 8, 2020 .

Still smarting from seeing the package whittled down from $6 trillion to $3.5 trillion to $1.75 trillion, liberals say the final result is not enough to push the progressive grassroots to the polls next year after top priorities were left on the cutting room floor.

Biden makes last-minute push for economic agenda before heading overseas

  Biden makes last-minute push for economic agenda before heading overseas President Joe Biden on Thursday was making a last-minute push for agenda before heading overseas. "No one got everything they wanted, including me, but that's what compromise is. That's consensus. And that's what I ran on," Biden said in remarks from the White House East Room.

What's more, they argue, the omission of provisions such as a national paid family leave program and a proposal to empower the federal government to negotiate lower prescription drug prices from the framework outlined by the White House this week amounts to a slap in the face to the progressive activists and groups who helped President Biden win in 2020.

"It's promising to see a substantial investment in climate action, but it's appalling and frankly cruel that drug pricing, paid leave, Medicare expansion on dental and vision, are all cut from the framework, and Biden seems willing to leave a pathway to citizenship for millions up to an unelected parliamentarian," said Varshini Prakash, the executive director of Sunrise Movement, a progressive group focused on climate issues.

Trump Praises Moderate Dems for Taking 'Total Advantage' of Progressives in Negotiations

  Trump Praises Moderate Dems for Taking 'Total Advantage' of Progressives in Negotiations "They promised the Progressives everything and are giving them nothing," the former president said.Progressives and moderate Democrats—mainly Senators Joe Manchin of West Virginia and Kyrsten Sinema of Arizona from the latter group—have been at odds for months as they've negotiated what will be included in the final budget reconciliation package as well as how much the final price tag will be. Biden and Democrats now appear close to a deal, however, with the initial $3.5 trillion proposal scaled down significantly to $1.75 trillion.

"Progressives are the ones who have fought like hell for Biden's full agenda, and their votes cannot be taken for granted," she added.

To be sure, the spending framework suggested by Biden on Thursday would still impose sweeping societal change, and what was left out of the proposal could become priorities for progressives after an ultimate bill is passed.

Many progressives are still lining up behind the framework, in some cases begrudgingly, believing that failing to pass anything at all would be politically self-destructive heading into a midterm election in which both of Democrats' congressional majorities are on the line.

They see the $1.75 trillion spending framework as an opening gambit that could pave the way for Democrats to extend and expand their priorities later on.

Cristina Tzintzún Ramirez, the president of the progressive NextGen America, said that the framework for the pared-down spending bill "represents a breach of democratic trust," blaming a small group of moderate Democrats for forcing the majority of their party to "renege on essential promises."

Tussling Dems tumble toward deal on Biden's economic plans

  Tussling Dems tumble toward deal on Biden's economic plans WASHINGTON (AP) — Fractious congressional Democrats coalesced significantly around President Joe Biden's multitrillion-dollar domestic ambitions last week. But the two measures boosting resources for social, environment and infrastructure programs remained works in progress, and lawmakers also managed to embarrass Biden and House Speaker Nancy Pelosi. That dissonance reflects how things routinely work in Congress, where legislating and politics are ungainly and often produce convoluted messages.

"Young Americans expected the leaders they elected to act and act quickly - on solving the climate crisis, reducing income inequality and building an economy that works for ordinary people," Tzintzún Ramirez said in a statement on Thursday.

"The Build Back Better Framework announced by the White House today doesn't go far enough to address the economic and climate crises facing our generation," she added.

Still, Tzintzún Ramirez said that her group would support the framework for the bill. She urged Democrats to move quickly to pass Biden's so-called Build Back Better framework as well as a $1 trillion infrastructure package and then "recommit themselves to fulfilling the promises that inspired millions of young people to join our democratic process in 2020."

For some liberals, however, the compromise on the spending framework underscores a deeper frustration. The spending framework was whittled down after running into stiff opposition from moderate Sens. Joe Manchin (D-W.Va.) and Kyrsten Sinema (D-Ariz.), frustrating progressives who see themselves as having earned more influence in Washington.

House Progressives and moderates united to pass a massive infrastructure deal

  House Progressives and moderates united to pass a massive infrastructure deal Democrats passed a $1.2 trillion infrastructure bill, but their larger climate and social spending bill is still in doubt.The result was a major step forward for President Joe Biden’s agenda, but a blow to progressives who’ve long pushed for the two bills to be tied together. Progressives were able to extract a commitment from House moderates to vote for the spending measure by November 15, although that pledge came with an important caveat.

"The understandable frustration of progressives is that we are anchored down and weighed down by people like Manchin and Sinema," said Jonathan Tasini, a progressive strategist and former national surrogate for Sen. Bernie Sanders's (I-Vt.) 2016 presidential campaign. "We want to transform the country, but you can't do that in this corrupt system."

"There's still a fight going on here," he continued. "We haven't taken control, and we have to admit it. We haven't transformed the Democratic Party, and we don't have the power to do it right now."

Still, Tasini said that it would be a "huge mistake for progressives to sink" the bill, arguing that Democrats would be wise to quickly approve the social spending and climate change plan before tackling other issues such as allowing Medicare to negotiate prescription drug prices.

"You have to pass this and fight on," he said. "It's about doing right for people. If you do good policy, the politics will follow."

The concerns about the size and expanse of the framework stem, in part, from Democrats' belief that they can stave off the kind of midterm thrashing typically dealt to a new president's party by enacting sweeping, transformational reforms that could prove their ability to govern effectively. Republicans need to flip just five seats in the House and only one in the Senate to reclaim control of Congress.

Democrats Hand Joe Biden His Long-Awaited Infrastructure Win

  Democrats Hand Joe Biden His Long-Awaited Infrastructure Win After a torturous series of never-ending Infrastructure Weeks, President Joe Biden and congressional Democrats took the largest step yet toward ending the political Groundhog Day. On Friday night, House Democrats passed a $1 trillion bipartisan infrastructure bill, 228-206, with 215 Democrats and 13 Republicans voting for the bill, and six Democrats and 200 Republicans voting no. Since it already passed the Senate, the so-called Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act now heads to Biden’s desk for his signature, allowing the president to claim a major win as his approval ratings sag.

And to be sure, many Democrats believe that the framework for the social policy and climate bill lives up to goal. Even if it falls short of the $3.5 trillion price tag initially backed by party leaders, $1.75 trillion would still be a historic investment.

Joshua Karp, a Democratic strategist, said most voters aren't concerned about the exact details of the framework but rather that it takes tangible steps toward fulfilling Democrats' agenda.

"I do believe that the voters will show up at the ballot box in November of next year because we kept our promises," Karp said. "Most voters are not following the minutiae of the individual bills here in D.C. The fact that Democrats did not win every priority in this bill is not going to be relevant next year."

"What's going to be important is, did we deliver significant progress for American families? And in these bills is a whole lot of progress."

Tyler Law, a Democratic strategist and former national press secretary for the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee, said that the fact that the framework was born out of compromise is actually beneficial for the party heading into 2022 because it shows that Democrats are capable of reaching a consensus.

"There's a benefit in voters seeing that we came to this through compromise," Law said. "People want compromise. No one has an expectation that they're going to get every single thing they want, but so long as you're delivering real results, something they can feel, something that really helps their families, that's the stuff that makes a difference in the midterms."

Of course, the fate of the spending proposal - and that of the $1 trillion infrastructure measure - isn't yet certain. Manchin and Sinema haven't offered any firm commitments on the framework, and House progressives are refusing to back the infrastructure bill until they see more tangible progress on the larger spending bill.

And if Democrats are able to pass the social policy and climate change bill, whether it serves to mobilize the party's base in 2022 will largely depend on how successful Democrats are in enacting - and selling - the legislation, said Fernand Amandi, a Democratic pollster.

"It's hard to see how these projects start to come online in a way that is absolutely noticeable between now and the elections next year," Amandi said.

"However, if the Democrats and the administration and the government are able to expedite the rollout of these projects so people start seeing and experiencing the impact of what this bill means to their lives and to the life of the country, then I think it could very well serve as a charge for increased Democratic turnout," Amandi added.

Jayapal explains how progressives chose pragmatism: 'We need to keep our eyes on the prize' .
The Congressional Progressive Caucus got the White House message -- no more delay. Members embraced a compromise economic package as the best available deal, and accepted private assurances of Senate support. © Andrew Harnik/AP Rep. Pramila Jayapal, D-Wash., speaks to reporters as she walks out of a House Democratic Progressive Caucus meeting on Capitol Hill in Washington, Thursday, Oct. 28, 2021. Then Joe Manchin, one of the recalcitrant senators they were counting on, went before television cameras to warn he might sink the negotiated plan.

See also