Politics: Report: Roberts tried to persuade rest of Supreme Court to keep Roe v. Wade in place

Some Democrats are pushing for a Hail Mary attempt to win over Manchin on a climate deal after September. The odds are stacked against them.

  Some Democrats are pushing for a Hail Mary attempt to win over Manchin on a climate deal after September. The odds are stacked against them. Democrats seem wary of going on another wild-goose chase to win over Senator Joe Manchin on climate after a year of negotiating chaos.Several Senate Democrats such as Sen. Ed Markey of Massachusetts are pressing for a Hail Mary shot to secure the support of Manchin on another spending package after September. Beginning with the new federal fiscal year in October, Democrats can craft another reconciliation bill separate from the one they aim to pass within weeks, also capable of skirting fierce GOP opposition and passing with only a simple majority vote. Democrats floated the maneuver last fall when final passage appeared achievable by the end of 2021.

WASHINGTON – One of the more interesting power dynamics from the Supreme Court's historic term that ended in June was the sidelining of Chief Justice John Roberts in one of the most important outcomes in years: the decision to overturn Roe v. Wade.

Roberts signaled during oral arguments in December that he wasn't keen to knock down the 1973 precedent that established a constitutional right to abortion. He reiterated the point in a concurrence when the ruling landed in June. Roberts supported upholding Mississippi's ban on most abortions after 15 weeks of pregnancy, but did not see the need to target Roe.

GOP Sen. Mike Lee is in a tight contest with independent Evan McMullin in the Utah Senate race: poll

  GOP Sen. Mike Lee is in a tight contest with independent Evan McMullin in the Utah Senate race: poll Jason Perry, the director of the Hinckley Institute of Politics, told Deseret News that Utah "has not seen a Senate race this competitive in decades."Biden is expected to make a final decision by the end of February to replace Breyer and has already begun to reach out to potential candidates, according to CNN.

The internal dynamics were reinforced by CNN reporting Tuesday. Citing unnamed sources, the network reported Roberts had tried to convince his colleagues to join his more limited approach to the abortion decision – and failed. The report raises the prospect that the dramatic leak of a draft opinion weeks earlier didn't help Roberts' effort.

Start the day smarter. Get all the news you need in your inbox each morning.

The chief: Roberts wanted to go slow ending Roe. His colleagues were in a hurry.

Grip: Roberts facing test of leadership amid tense time at Supreme Court

Here's what we know about Roberts' role in the abortion case.

Who is Chief Justice John Roberts?

John Roberts is the 17th chief justice of the United States. A former federal appeals court judge, he was nominated to the Supreme Court by President George W. Bush in 2005 and confirmed by the Senate later that year on a 78-22 vote.

Former GOP House lawmaker is charged with violating insider trading laws to buy $1.5 million in stock

  Former GOP House lawmaker is charged with violating insider trading laws to buy $1.5 million in stock Prosecutors say former Rep. Stephen Buyer heard about Sprint's merger with T-Mobile during a golf game before the news became public.Stephen Buyer, a former Indiana congressman, learned of T-Mobile's plan to acquire Sprint during a March 2018 golf outing with an unnamed T-Mobile executive, the Securities and Exchange Commission alleged on Monday. According to a SEC complaint, Buyer then purchased $568,000 of Sprint shares based on the non-public knowledge ahead of the formal announcement of the massive merger.

Bio: What to know about John Roberts, chief justice of the United States

Overall, Roberts and Associate Justice Brett Kavanaugh remain in the ideological center of the court. Both justices were in the majority in 95% of the court's decisions in the term that ended in June, according to statistics compiled by SCOTUSblog.

Why did some think Roberts could save Roe?

Roberts has demonstrated an ability to build majorities around narrow rulings in the past – the kind of incremental outcomes that left neither liberals nor conservatives particularly happy when the court wrapped up each term. Often viewed as supporting incremental outcomes, Roberts is especially worried about the high court's reputation if the public views its rulings as being driven by politics.

Soft power: How Chief Justice John Roberts is exerting influence

What did Roberts say about Roe?

In the Mississippi case, Roberts didn't join the majority to overturn Roe. Instead, he articulated what some saw as the centrist's position: He wanted to uphold the Mississippi ban on most abortions after 15 weeks of pregnancy at issue in the case, but not overrule one of the Supreme Court's best recognized precedents.

The Supreme Court will likely enter new territory on abortion rights as thorny questions over rape, interstate travel, and data privacy roil the country

  The Supreme Court will likely enter new territory on abortion rights as thorny questions over rape, interstate travel, and data privacy roil the country "There are major, important questions yet to be addressed," one legal expert said. "The court still has a lot of work to do in this area."Roe v. Wade, which established a federal right to abortion nearly 50 years ago, was an "abuse of judicial authority" that "sparked a national controversy," Justice Samuel Alito, the author of the monumental June 24 ruling, wrote in the majority opinion.

Upholding the Mississippi law, he wrote, is as far as he would have gone "out of adherence to a simple yet fundamental principle of judicial restraint: If it is not necessary to decide more to dispose of a case, then it is necessary not to decide more."

In the end, no other justice joined that view.

The vote to overturn Roe was 5-4. The vote to uphold Mississippi's ban was 6-3.

"To write alone is truly kind of interesting as the chief," Glenn Cohen, a professor and deputy dean at Harvard Law School told USA TODAY in June. "One feels a little bit that this is his moment of shouting into the desert as a judicial minimalist."

Associate Justice Samuel Alito, writing for the majority in the abortion case, countered that Roberts' approach would have simply kept the controversy alive, prompting similar appeals over 14-week bans, 12-week bans and so on.

Chief Justice of the United States John Roberts on Jan. 29, 2020. © Patrick Semansky, AP Chief Justice of the United States John Roberts on Jan. 29, 2020.

Did Roberts lobby colleagues behind the scenes?

In the cloistered halls of the Supreme Court it's often difficult to determine what's happening behind the scenes between the nine justices. But it is generally the case that the justices try to convince each other of their positions – sometimes in personal meetings and sometimes through the distribution of draft opinions.

6 Democrats introduce longshot bill to put term limits on Supreme Court, citing a post-Roe 'legitimacy crisis'

  6 Democrats introduce longshot bill to put term limits on Supreme Court, citing a post-Roe 'legitimacy crisis' The group of lawmakers wants to see new justices join the court every two years, forcing older justices aside in a radical overhaul of the top court.The opinion was written by Justice Samuel Alito and supported by conservative justices Clarence Thomas, Neil Gorsuch, Brett Kavanaugh, and Amy Coney Barrett, three of whom were appointed by former President Donal Trump.

Whodunit: Answers scarce on who leaked draft Supreme Court abortion opinion

A report in CNN on Tuesday, citing unnamed sources, suggested Roberts was leaning on his conservative colleagues right up until the court handed down its decision on June 24. In May, in the middle of that effort, an early draft of the opinion was leaked. The unprecedented disclosure, many have speculated, might have made it harder for any justice to switch their vote if it appeared that they were caving to the backlash the draft opinion prompted from abortion rights supporters.

"Leaking this early draft makes that more costly for a defector because now people will think that they changed their vote after the leak," Kermit Roosevelt, a professor at the University of Pennsylvania Carey Law School, had speculated to USA TODAY in an interview earlier this year.

This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Report: Roberts tried to persuade rest of Supreme Court to keep Roe v. Wade in place

Roberts tried to persuade SCOTUS to keep Roe v. Wade, proposed Griner deal: 5 Things podcast .
The U.S. offers Russia a prisoner swap proposal for Brittney Griner and Paul Whelan, a dinosaur skeleton will be auctioned off: 5 Things podcastSupreme Court correspondent John Fritze has the latest. Plus, the U.S. makes a prisoner swap proposal for Brittney Griner, patient safety reporter Karen Weintraub has more on obesity in America, slain journalist Shireen Abu Akleh's family wants a full investigation into her death and a dinosaur skeleton will be auctioned off for millions of dollars.

See also