Sport: With Deshaun Watson settlement talks off table, the NFL will be forced to render judgement in its investigation

Adam Schefter Gives Major Update On Deshaun Watson’s Future With Texans

  Adam Schefter Gives Major Update On Deshaun Watson’s Future With Texans During ESPN’s live NFL Draft coverage on Saturday, Adam Schefter dropped an eye-opening update on Deshaun Watson‘s future with the Houston Texans. What a whirlwind couple of months it’s been for Watson and the Texans. It began when the young superstar demanded a trade. In past weeks, the situation has been taken to a downward […] The post Adam Schefter Gives Major Update On Deshaun Watson’s Future With Texans appeared first on The Spun.

HOUSTON — A moment of clarity arrived for the Houston Texans' Deshaun Watson with Thursday’s revelation that four women met with NFL investigators regarding their civil lawsuits against the star quarterback. The league now has testimony from some of Watson’s accusers, and one way or another, it will have to decide what to do with that information.

It’s a crossroads between Watson’s civil litigation and an NFL investigation that was never guaranteed to materialize given the reality that the Texans star could have reached a group settlement and nondisclosure agreements with the 22 women accusing him of varying degrees of sexual misconduct. Such an event might have prevented any of Watson’s accusers from speaking to the NFL as part of its probe. But with the news of four of the women having spoken with league investigative czar Lisa Friel (or representatives from her office), it creates two realities for Watson.

Urban Meyer weighs in on Tim Tebow possibly joining Jaguars

  Urban Meyer weighs in on Tim Tebow possibly joining Jaguars Meyer did add that he was dissatisfied with the Jaguars’ current crop of tight ends, although Jacksonville drafted Ohio State’s Luke Farrell in the fifth round. The coach said the position was “a concern” for the Jaguars, adding that if Tebow could help Jacksonville win, Meyer would be in favor of adding his former quarterback at Florida.“I have one job, and that is to win games with the Jacksonville Jaguars. If Tim Tebow or Travis Etienne can help us win, then that’s my job to get them ready to go play,” Meyer added. “That decision is certainly not made yet.

First, NFL investigators will mandate that the quarterback meet with them for questioning before some kind of determination in the case; and second, Watson will now lack at least some settlement motivation, given that at least four of his accusers have cooperated with the NFL’s investigation.

What does all of this mean for Watson and his civil litigation? At the very least it will have ripple effects, depending on how Watson’s defense team absorbs the developments. Among them …

The civil litigation of the 22 women vs. Deshaun Watson

First and foremost, it doesn’t appear Watson’s civil litigation is going anywhere anytime soon. That’s a small revelation after the opposing attorneys in the disputes — Rusty Hardin representing Watson, and Tony Buzbee representing the 22 women — went completely silent following an April 22 status hearing in the cases. In that hearing, both sides accused the other of destroying digital evidence, leading a judge to place a preservation order and set the stage for litigation to move forward into discovery planning.

NHL's COVID protocol-related absences for May 7, 2021

  NHL's COVID protocol-related absences for May 7, 2021 Players in the COVID protocol are: Colorado's Devan Dubnyk and Washington's Evgeny Kuznetsov.Anaheim – TBA

After that spark-filled status hearing, neither Buzbee nor Hardin made a public statement for nearly three weeks, fueling speculation that the two sides may have gone to the negotiating table in hopes of developing settlement talks. Buzbee and Hardin appeared to blow up any settlement talks in the past 24 hours, when each made competing statements that settlements would not be happening.

Buzbee made the declaration while lauding the Houston Police Department for its handling of the alleged victims, and chiding the NFL for meetings with four of his clients that he deemed to be lacking respect.

Conversely, Hardin concurred there would be no settlement talks while pointing a finger at Buzbee as being the party that has continually tried to engineer them. Hardin said, via statement:

In a recent interview, Mr. Buzbee stated that “a settlement is not happening.” We certainly agree that there are currently no settlement negotiations being conducted. While we have never approached Mr. Buzbee about a settlement, he has approached us on numerous occasions in the past about the possibility of a settlement. We have made clear all along that there would be no settlement unless the terms are made public and all participants are allowed to speak in their own defense at all times. We want none of the participants— the plaintiffs or Mr. Watson —muzzled by a settlement agreement. Mr. Buzbee does not feel the same.

I am a little bemused by Mr. Buzbee pronouncing piously that his clients are not going to settle and that they want their cases to play out in court. The fact that this whole thing started with his attempt to extort money and avoid court shows that irony is not dead. I guess it has just been raised to a new level.

Texans HC David Culley Asked About Deshaun Watson’s Status For OTAs, Camp

  Texans HC David Culley Asked About Deshaun Watson’s Status For OTAs, Camp First-year Houston Texans head coach David Culley inherited one of the trickiest situations in the NFL when he was hired, with star quarterback Deshaun Watson demanding a trade from the franchise. That situation has only grown more precarious, as more than 20 women have com forward to accuse Watson of a range of alleged sexual […] The post Texans HC David Culley Asked About Deshaun Watson’s Status For OTAs, Camp appeared first on The Spun.

Regardless of who wants what, the underlying theme is simple: Both lawyers want the world to know that as of right now, the litigation is going to press forward.

For Buzbee, neither the Houston Police investigation nor the NFL’s probe guarantee his success or failure in trying the civil cases against Watson. But the cooperation of the alleged victims with both (or either) of those investigations potentially impacts whether Watson could be inclined to settle the civil cases. And now that Buzbee has made it clear that a handful of the women in civil litigation have provided interviews with the HPD and the NFL, it will almost certainly weigh into the strategy of Watson’s defense team moving forward.

Deshaun Watson et al. that are standing in the snow: The lawyer for Deshaun Watson says the Houston QB won't settle with the 22 women who are accusing him in civil lawsuits of varying degrees of sexual misconduct. (Photo by Bob Levey/Getty Images) © Provided by Yahoo! Sports The lawyer for Deshaun Watson says the Houston QB won't settle with the 22 women who are accusing him in civil lawsuits of varying degrees of sexual misconduct. (Photo by Bob Levey/Getty Images)

The Houston Police Department and NFL investigations

If Buzbee is to be taken at his word in his most recent statements, he appears to have reflected positively on the Houston Police Department’s investigation and negatively on the NFL’s probe. That could be important to Watson’s defense, particularly if Watson’s attorneys didn't know how many accusers had spoken to HPD and NFL investigators.

Report: When Deshaun Watson Will Be Deposed In Legal Case

  Report: When Deshaun Watson Will Be Deposed In Legal Case Those wondering what the future holds for Deshaun Watson might be waiting for quite a while. Watson is facing lawsuits from 22 women who alleged the Houston Texans quarterback sexually assaulted them. On Tuesday afternoon, the NFL world learned just how long it will take for Watson to be deposed in the case. According to […] The post Report: When Deshaun Watson Will Be Deposed In Legal Case appeared first on The Spun.

Buzbee’s statements now provide Watson’s legal camp with two revelations to absorb. First, Buzbee is framing the interaction of the Houston Police Department as not only active and ongoing, but he expressed appreciation for how the investigators of the criminal complaints have handled the proceedings. And second, Buzbee’s criticism of the NFL’s investigative meetings with four accusers is suggestive on its face that he is discouraged by the state of the league’s probe (or at least how investigators are handling Watson’s accusers during their work).

In both respects, Buzbee’s statements could make Watson less inclined to engage in a mass settlement of the cases — especially if his legal camp had prioritized a non-disclosure of information to police or the NFL in any agreement. Regardless of whether Buzbee views the HPD investigation in a positive light and the NFL investigation in a negative light, the overriding takeaway is that the civil accusers have already gone down a road of cooperation in both. And that choice could remove some motivation from Watson to settle if he feels things have gone past the point of no return.

Where does the NFL go from here?

Noteworthy in all of the latest revelations is the fact the NFL now has information that goes beyond the civil filings against Watson. By Buzbee’s account, the league has the testimony of four women and that could be an important threshold for the NFL when it comes to making a determination about Watson’s future.

If Antonio Brown’s now-settled civil case with former trainer Britney Taylor is used as a road map — not to mention a litany of other assault-related investigations undertaken by the NFL — one of the next steps will be a meeting with Watson to question him on the basis of the information and interviews gathered. While the NFL could wait for the Houston Police Department’s investigation to unfold, the reality is that just like Brown’s dispute with Taylor, the league doesn’t have to wait for litigation or a police investigation to make a determination of its own.

Ranking 2021 NFL divisions from top to bottom, plus Packers wideouts skipping OTAs with Aaron Rodgers

  Ranking 2021 NFL divisions from top to bottom, plus Packers wideouts skipping OTAs with Aaron Rodgers Here's everything you need to know about the NFL for May 26This is the Pick Six Newsletter. Now let's get to it. (And please, do yourself a favor and make sure you're signed up to receive this newsletter every day! You don't want to miss our daily offerings of everything you need to know around the NFL.

The bottom line revelation: The league has civil suits and first-person interviews. That material, along with a Watson interview, is enough to rise to some kind of determination from NFL commissioner Roger Goodell, particularly if past situations serve as a judicial framework under the league’s personal conduct policy. And even if the league is still in an early phase of its work, the first-person interviews and litigation can serve as enough to decide whether or not Watson should be on paid leave via the commissioner’s exempt list.

One way or another, the NFL is now going to have to render some kind of decision with Watson. Either the league will determine there is enough evidence to meet the standard that a violation of the personal conduct policy may have occurred, or the NFL will find that there isn’t enough evidence to do anything. Both of those are forms of judgements — one by taking action, and one by doing nothing at all.

More from Yahoo Sports:

  • Target halts sale of sports cards after fight breaks out

  • Wetzel: Brady vs. Belichick will be showdown like no other

  • USA Football condemns violent viral video of tackling drill

  • Negley: WNBA launches Commissioner's Cup tourney

David Culley Has Blunt Response To Deshaun Watson Question .
Deshaun Watson didn’t report to Texans OTAs this week, amidst his rift with the organization and his ongoing legal situation, after 22 women accused the 25-year-old of sexual misconduct. Despite the uncertainty swirling around the NFL quarterback, it doesn’t seem like any update will be coming from Houston’s coaching staff. Throughout the week at the […] The post David Culley Has Blunt Response To Deshaun Watson Question appeared first on The Spun.

See also