TOP News

Sport: Would the Patriots still have won big if Tom Brady didn’t take pay cuts?

Bill Belichick thinks Tom Brady can play until age 50

  Bill Belichick thinks Tom Brady can play until age 50 Bill Belichick and Tom Brady are about to face off against each other for the first time next weekend. So the Patriots head coach and the Buccaneers quarterback are expected to be asked a lot of questions about each other ahead of the reunion. © Kirby Lee-USA TODAY Sports WEEI 93.7 in Boston got that ball rolling on Monday morning when Belichick joined the broadcast. The first matter of business? Brady's recent remarks that he could play until he is 50 years old."I’m sure Tom would know better than anybody, so if anybody can do it it’s him," Belichick said. Will @TomBrady play until he's 50?"I think I can.

The Tom Brady-Patriots marriage is one of the most complicated relationships in NFL history.

There's a lot to unpack between the decades-long dynastic duo of Brady and Bill Belichick, their bitter divorce in 2020 and the subsequent championship run of Brady as a Tampa Bay Buccaneer this past season. And now, as Brady returns to Foxborough to face his old team for the first time, a lot of hyperbole has emerged about how Brady and the Patriots built one of, if not the greatest, sports runs ever.

One of the bigger fallacies surrounding the Patriots’ 20-season run with Brady, though, is the notion they needed their quarterback to consistently take pay cuts to be able to construct championship-contending teams.

As reunion looms, Tom Brady remains ultimate example of Bill Belichick's successful but uncompromising ways

  As reunion looms, Tom Brady remains ultimate example of Bill Belichick's successful but uncompromising ways Amid the plaudits being sent back and forth between Tom Brady and Bill Belichick as they prepare for Sunday’s Tampa Bay-New England game in Foxborough, there remains an underlying question fueling the soap opera that is the NFL. Belichick is 8-11 in that time. Last week Brady noted his “respect” and “admiration” for Belichick. Anyway, that’s all fine, but Brady is running a proxy battle most pointedly via his trainer, Alex Guerrero, who theorized that Belichick drove Brady out by how he treated him. “I think [Belichick’s] emotions or feelings never evolved with age," Guerrero told the Boston Herald.

While Brady routinely took less money than his contemporaries — one analysis by Business Insider estimated he left $60 million-$100 million on the table — the effect it had on the Patriots’ ability to build a franchise that went 249-75 during his tenure is exaggerated. Brady’s discounts theoretically only added 1.62-2.8 wins over 15 years if he consistently signed a top-five contract each time he was due for an extension, according to an analysis by Pro Football Focus' Timo Maske. That’s a surprisingly low number considering Brady was only a top-five-paid quarterback six times in his career and only the highest-paid quarterback once.

With quarterback contracts being what they are today, the top ones making upwards of $40 million a year, it would stand to reason the Patriots wouldn’t have had enough cap space to build a talented roster if Brady constantly maxed out his money every season he was eligible.

Bill Belichick surprises some people with comment about Tom Brady

  Bill Belichick surprises some people with comment about Tom Brady Bill Belichick may feel he can rebuild the New England Patriots into a championship contender without Tom Brady, but that doesn’t mean the coach takes for granted everything that Brady helped him accomplish.With the New England Patriots set to host the Tampa Bay Buccaneers this weekend, both Belichick and Brady have faced a barrage of questions about one another and the 20 seasons they spent together. Belichick was asked on Friday if he believes his résumé would look the same today had he not coached Brady. Some were surprised to hear him state the obvious.

(Erick Parra Monroy/Yahoo Sports) © Provided by Yahoo! Sports (Erick Parra Monroy/Yahoo Sports)

But the difference between Brady's deals and the quarterbacks paid more than him isn't why the Patriots were so good. It's a classic "causation doesn’t always equal correlation" situation. Just because Brady always took less than top dollar didn’t automatically mean the Patriots were always good, it just meant that Brady was always good and the Patriots were smart with their money. New England simply never overspent in free agency and instead spent the extra money on value contracts or to re-sign and extend their own players.

That approach wouldn't have changed if Brady was taking up more of the salary cap.

“That would be a very accurate assessment,” Scott Pioli, the Patriots’ former vice president of player personnel from 2002-08, said of this hypothesis. “It’s not like he was grossly underpaid … [but] it allowed us more flexibility to extend other people, to bring in other people, to extend other good players that we drafted, or just to have cap flexibility to do more things.”

Dems keep talking, reproductive rights marches, Brady vs. Patriots: 5 things to know this weekend

  Dems keep talking, reproductive rights marches, Brady vs. Patriots: 5 things to know this weekend Stopgap measures get prepped as Democrats continue talks on two huge bills, Tom Brady takes on the Patriots and more news to start your weekend.Start the day smarter. Get all the news you need in your inbox each morning.

The first opportunity Brady could have cashed in was in 2005. Peyton Manning had signed a seven-year, $98 million contract the year before and Brady was coming off back-to-back Super Bowl wins in 2003 and 2004. But rather than hunker down and negotiate for Manning money, Brady accepted a slightly smaller six-year, $60 million contract.

“He felt that if you left some money on the table, it would allow us to have a chance to get more good players around him," Pioli added. "The more good players we had around him, the better team we would have, therefore potentially the better chance to win more. Tommy’s method of measurement has always been about championships, not, you know, the world seeing how much money he makes.”

The rest of Brady's contracts over the years mirror that mentality. He was never a top-five highest-paid quarterback every time the Patriots played in a Super Bowl. It's a stark difference between the actual highest-paid quarterbacks at the time, as explained in this 3D augmented reality experience:

The line of demarcation between when Brady's deals weren't far from the top and when they starting creeping toward massive discounts is 2013, when Brady signed a three-year, $41 million deal at the age of 36. Between 2005-12, Brady, on average, was around the sixth- or seventh-highest paid quarterback every year, and the Patriots made the Super Bowl (and lost) just twice. From 2014-18, he averaged out as the 12th- or 13th-highest paid quarterback, and the Patriots went to four Super Bowls and won three of them.

Tom Brady hair: A timeline of the Buccaneers QB's hairstyles, from bowl cut to Belieber

  Tom Brady hair: A timeline of the Buccaneers QB's hairstyles, from bowl cut to Belieber Franchise QBs have franchise-QB looks. Brady is no stranger to the idea — he did marry a supermodel, after all.Ah, yes, the football GOAT is as legendary for his follicular fables as he is his storied career on the field. Brady's salad has often been the subject of much discussion and fanfare, with good reason: The guy married a supermodel, after all, and just being good at football isn't enough of a reason for that to happen.

That window is when you could make the argument the Patriots benefited from Brady's discounts. He left roughly left $29.4 million-$31 million on the table — depending on if you compare his deals exclusively to Manning, or to the highest earners every year — over his final seven seasons in New England, according to Over the Cap's Jason Fitzgerald. The Patriots used that extra space to build an offensive line to protect Brady and a solid defense behind him.

But the Patriots didn't use the extra $4 million per season to sign a game-breaking receiver, bruising pass rusher or shutdown corner. Instead, they drafted well (13 starters), traded for cheap but productive players, like running back LeGarrette Blount, and signed bargains like Danny Amendola to fit their offense. They also jettisoned aging players looking for big deals to open up cap space. The extra money helped, sure, but it didn't make or break the Patriots during this time.

As Brady and the Patriots moved forward, that team-friendly ideology began to wane, according to Seth Wickersham's new book, "It's Better to Be Feared." In it, Wickersham writes that Brady wanted input on roster construction during the latter years of his time in New England and that lack of influence affected his decision to leave in 2020.

Tom Brady’s career in New England: Draft info, debut, overall record with Belichick & more

  Tom Brady’s career in New England: Draft info, debut, overall record with Belichick & more Tonight on NBC features a match-up between the Tampa Bay Buccaneers and the New England Patriots as Tom Brady returns to Foxborough for the first time since switching teams in 2020. See below for everything you need to know about Brady’s tenure in New England. Live coverage begins at 7:00 p.m. ET with Football Night in America. Tonight’s match-up will also be available via live stream on Peacock. RELATED: Buccaneers vs Patriots – Will Tom Brady break the NFL’s passing yards record? Tom Brady’s Tenure in New England: When was Tom Brady drafted? Tom Brady was drafted by the New England Patriots on April 16th, 2000 at just 22 years old.

"Brady was tired of taking team-friendly deals with no input into how the money saved was spent — and still wanted a long-term contractual commitment," Wickersham writes. "Belichick told associates that every organizational decision now was in support of Brady, geared toward pleasing him and making him successful — and that Kraft meddled with the team, sometimes with opinions, sometimes with restrictive budgets."

That new line of thinking by Brady diametrically opposed the original idea behind his contract decisions. He took less money because it meant a better team. But when he disagreed with what the Patriots did with the money, taking a smaller deal didn't look as enticing anymore.

The bubble burst in 2020, and the Patriots were left with a talent-depleted team and no franchise quarterback. But the remnants of Brady's selflessness remained this past season: The Patriots still finished a respectable 7-9 despite no long-term future and a team ravaged by COVID-19 opt-outs and aging contracts. The 2021 Patriots, though, are something else entirely. Belichick spent lavishly in free agency to fill the talent void left by Brady, and New England sits at 1-2 with a thus far middling rookie quarterback in Mac Jones.

Belichick will finally get to face the Patriots' own team-building strategy this weekend against Brady's Buccaneers. Brady remains an underpaid quarterback on a contender flush with homegrown talent, a great offensive line and even better defense.

Who knows what will happen Sunday night? But there's no arguing what happened the past two decades.

Bruce Arians has funny reaction to Tom Brady getting booed at Hall of Fame .
There were times when Manning got the best of Brady in the postseason, but Brady did most of the winning. That’s why Manning’s fans tend to not be fond of Brady, and vice versa. Video: Joy Taylor: It's not Super Bowl or bust for Patrick Mahomes; Tom Brady created these expectations I FIRST THINGS FIRST (FOXSports) Your browser does not support this video Manning cracked some great jokes during his Hall of Fame speech about Brady and other players. It was all in good fun, and so were the boos.Subscribe to Yardbarker's Morning Bark, the most comprehensive newsletter in sports.

See also