US: Please Stop Fawning Over Sheryl Sandberg’s Dinky Abortion Rights Donation

University Of Idaho Warns Employees Could Face Felony Charges If They Promote Abortion Or Contraception

  University Of Idaho Warns Employees Could Face Felony Charges If They Promote Abortion Or Contraception A state law prohibits any public funds from being used on abortion or promoting services for “the prevention of conception,” including in schools.The university’s Office of General Counsel sent guidance for employees on how to comply with state laws regulating abortion and contraception, noting the school is “committed to operating within the confines of laws.

Days after she stepped down as COO of Meta (née Facebook), Sheryl Sandberg revealed on Tuesday that she has pledged $3 million, spread out over the next three years, to the American Civil Liberties Union for its advocacy on abortion rights.

This woman can afford to give much, much more $3 million to the fight for abortion rights. Kevin Dietsch/Getty Images © Provided by Slate This woman can afford to give much, much more $3 million to the fight for abortion rights. Kevin Dietsch/Getty Images

Dozens of news outlets reported the announcement as a major turning point in the battle against mounting abortion restrictions in the U.S.—and a new chapter for Sandberg as a public figure. The Washington Post said Sandberg is “remaking herself as one of the foremost philanthropists fighting the curtailment of abortion rights across the United States.” Bloomberg called her “one of [the ACLU’s] biggest benefactors.”

Critics allege double standard in FBI arrest of anti-abortion activist

  Critics allege double standard in FBI arrest of anti-abortion activist The arrest of an anti-abortion activist on federal charges has touched off a firestorm of criticism and accusations of a double standard in the enforcement of protections for reproductive care centers. FBI agents arrested Mark Houck, founder of a Catholic ministry in Pennsylvania, on Friday for allegedly violating the Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act, which protects reproductive care facilities of any kind from threats or attacks.

Those claims are technically true, I guess, though the only reason why Sandberg has been able to claim a spot among the top funders of abortion-rights work is that there are just a few hundred billionaires in the U.S., many of them are conservative, and a small fraction are women. Richer billionaires than Sandberg have also committed much more to the cause: MacKenzie Scott gave $275 million to Planned Parenthood earlier this year; others have given several million per year, while Sandberg has made two $1 million donations to Planned Parenthood in years past.

Meanwhile, the rush to publish headlines about Sandberg’s measly $1-million-a-year pledge seems a bit credulous of the potential impact of her gift. The Washington Post reports that it’s “one of the biggest donations for abortion rights in ACLU history.” (Emphasis mine, obviously.) If you have to add so many vague qualifiers to your impressive claim, maybe your claim isn’t that impressive.

Five ways California is protecting abortion

  Five ways California is protecting abortion Lawmakers and abortion rights advocates want California to serve as a model for other blue states.With the midterms just weeks away and a number of the state’s congressional races hinging on the issue, the governor approved a sweeping reproductive rights package designed to shield patients and clinicians from criminal investigations, defray the costs of traveling to California for the procedure and expand the number of people who can perform abortions, among other changes.

Is the gift a big deal for the ACLU? Possibly. But it pales in comparison to other donations that got such dedicated promotional hype from the organization. I could only find a few other recent donation announcements in the ACLU’s archive of press releases, and they were all for pledges of $15 million or more. In the fiscal year 2021, the ACLU received $360.5 million in donations and grants. (That’s not including what state affiliates bring in.) If Sandberg splits up her donation equally over the three-year term of her pledge, her 2022 payout will likely make up less than 0.2 percent of what the organization raises this year.

Is the gift a big deal in the grand scheme of abortion access funding? Meh. It could certainly pay for a lot of abortions, but that’s not what the money is going toward. It’s going to political advocacy and voter outreach. To put $3 million over three years in perspective, NARAL, the Planned Parenthood Action Fund, and EMILY’s List are collectively spending about $150 million on the 2022 midterm elections.

Michigan women fight to preserve abortion, 1 chat at a time

  Michigan women fight to preserve abortion, 1 chat at a time UTICA, Mich. (AP) — At a wine bar in suburban Detroit, about a dozen women strategized about how to preserve the right to abortion in their state. This was not a typical political event; there were no microphones, no literature to hand out and few who would consider themselves activists. Among them was a mother of four whose only previous political experience was pushing for later school start times, a busy medical student and a retired teacher who, at 75, has never felt comfortable knocking on doors or cold calling for a candidate. © Provided by Associated Press Kelly Dillaha talks during a Red Wine and Blue event in Utica, Mich., Tuesday, Sept. 20, 2022.

According to the ACLU, Sandberg’s donation will be used in part to “support ballot measures protecting abortion access.” The organization has already spent at least $6 million in Michigan alone on a ballot measure that would add the right to abortion to the state constitution if voters approve it this year. I have never seen such fanfare over the funding of a fraction of a ballot-measure campaign.

But the question I’m most interested in, because the spoils of this publicity push seem to be accruing mostly to Sandberg, is this: Is the $3 million a big deal for her?

In 2021, as COO of Meta, Sandberg made about $35.2 million in total compensation, including Meta stocks. (That’s before her outside income from investments, book sales, et cetera.) A $3 million donation spread out over three years is the equivalent of donating less than 3 percent of that compensation per year. A nice chunk of change to a single organization, but not quite a sacrifice.

Here’s another way to look at it: Sandberg has an estimated net worth of $1.5 billion, according to Forbes. (Bloomberg puts it at $2.1 billion, but to be fair to Sandberg, let’s go with the conservative estimate.) There are 1,500 millions in 1.5 billion. Sandberg has pledged to give away three of those millions, which is 0.2 percent of her net worth.

Democrats stake their House majority on abortion

  Democrats stake their House majority on abortion Abortion policy has been featured in one-third of the party's broadcast TV ads to keep the House.Democratic candidates, their party’s campaign arm and allied super PACs have spent nearly $18 million to air more than 100 abortion-centered broadcast TV ads in some four dozen battleground seats as of the end of September, according to a POLITICO analysis of data from AdImpact, a media tracking firm. That sum is already three times more than what Democrats spent on abortion ads during the entire 2018 general election.

I just calculated 0.2 percent of my own net worth, and it is less than the price of a mid-range Ikea sofa, which I could easily shell out for today without thinking twice about it.

If you want some more numbers to contextualize $3 million from Sanders’ vantage point, here they are: In 2019 alone, according to an IRS filing, the investments held by Sandberg’s primary charitable foundation brought in more than $28.8 million—more than nine times the amount she has pledged to the ACLU. And Facebook spent $2.3 million in just one year on Sandberg’s personal use of private planes.

So, when you think about it, $3 million over three years for an entire news cycle about one’s new life as a philanthropist on the right side of history is a pretty good deal for Sanders, what with her fraught legacy and Facebook’s history of funding the right-wing groups that triggered the demise of our right to abortion in the first place. Puck’s Theodore Schleifer reports that, in conversations with progressive fundraisers, Sandberg has emerged as the least appealing prospective billionaire donor due to her and Facebook’s ethical baggage. She is lucky to have finally found a taker!

I’m not saying Sandberg shouldn’t have made her pledge, or that it won’t help the fight for legal abortion on a state and local level. I’m sure this money will make some kind of difference—probably most dramatically in the lives of ACLU employees, who will be able to hire a bit more staff, fund a few new TV commercials, or (heh) buy a bunch of extra Facebook ads for their ballot measure campaigns.

I just think that we, the media, ought not to fawn over a philanthropic gesture that, as a proportion of Sandberg’s overall wealth, is the kind of cash you wouldn’t even need to check with your spouse before spending. Laundering your reputation after running one of the most socially toxic companies in the world should not be that cheap or easy. Unfortunately, in the U.S., at this desperate moment in women’s rights, it just might be. So, hey, as the saying goes, be the change you wish to find in the cracks between your Ikea sofa cushions!

College Students Are Fighting For Abortion Rights on Campus Post Roe v. Wade .
“I wish I didn’t have to do this to get people what they need, but we’re here and we exist.”Sometimes, when Molly is tabling for abortion rights with other members of the Islander Feminists, a student club for intersectional feminism, they’re approached by members of church groups. One interaction sticks in Molly’s mind: when an older church leader came over to the Islander Feminists table and stood in front of it, seemingly to dissuade students from stopping to get resources. “He asked us if we’d had abortions and if we know what that means,” Molly says. “He asked what our religious beliefs are and why we believe murder is alright.

See also