World: Families seek truth as Airbus, Air France face crash trial

Air France Copies Lufthansa With Airbus A350 Orchestra Stunt

  Air France Copies Lufthansa With Airbus A350 Orchestra Stunt The Radio France Philarmonic Orchestra, directed by the director and A320 pilot Daniel Harding, performed in front of an Air France Airbus A350On October 1st, a new film will be released by Arte Concert and France Musique featuring the Radio France Philarmonic Orchestra performing the timeless masterpiece of Igor Stravinsky, "The Firebird".

PARIS (AP) — Nicolas Touillou had just proposed marriage to his girlfriend. Nelson Marinho Jr. was heading off on a new oil exploration job. Eric Lamy was about to celebrate his 38th birthday.

FILE - Workers unload debris, belonging to the crashed Air France flight AF447, from the Brazilian Navy's Constitution Frigate in the port of Recife, northeast of Brazil, June 14, 2009. It was the worst plane crash in Air France history, killing people of 33 nationalities and having lasting impact. It led to changes in air safety regulations, how pilots are trained and the use of airspeed sensors. (AP Photo/Eraldo Peres, File) © Provided by The Associated Press FILE - Workers unload debris, belonging to the crashed Air France flight AF447, from the Brazilian Navy's Constitution Frigate in the port of Recife, northeast of Brazil, June 14, 2009. It was the worst plane crash in Air France history, killing people of 33 nationalities and having lasting impact. It led to changes in air safety regulations, how pilots are trained and the use of airspeed sensors. (AP Photo/Eraldo Peres, File)

They were among 228 people killed in 2009 when their storm-tossed Air France flight from Rio de Janeiro to Paris slammed into the Atlantic. After more than a decade of legal battles, their families at last have a chance at justice.

6 People in Their 20s Killed After 'Devastating Overnight Crash' in Nebraska: 'Our Hearts Are Heavy'

  6 People in Their 20s Killed After 'Devastating Overnight Crash' in Nebraska: 'Our Hearts Are Heavy' “This is the worst crash in Lincoln in recent memory,” police wrote in a statementSix people in their twenties died following a "devastating overnight crash" in Lincoln, Nebraska, according to police.

Aviation industry heavyweights Airbus and Air France are charged with manslaughter in a trial that opens Monday over the crash of Flight 447 on June 1, 2009. The worst plane crash in Air France history killed people of 33 nationalities and had lasting impact, leading to changes in air safety regulations, how pilots are trained and the use of airspeed sensors.

Ophelie Toulliou, sister of a victim of the Rio-Paris plane crash, speaks during an interview with The Associated Press in Sannois, outside Paris, Friday, Oct. 7, 2022. It was the worst plane crash in Air France history, killing people of 33 nationalities and having lasting impact. It led to changes in air safety regulations, how pilots are trained and the use of airspeed sensors. (AP Photo/Christophe Ena) © Provided by The Associated Press Ophelie Toulliou, sister of a victim of the Rio-Paris plane crash, speaks during an interview with The Associated Press in Sannois, outside Paris, Friday, Oct. 7, 2022. It was the worst plane crash in Air France history, killing people of 33 nationalities and having lasting impact. It led to changes in air safety regulations, how pilots are trained and the use of airspeed sensors. (AP Photo/Christophe Ena)

But it almost didn’t come to trial. The companies insist they are not criminally responsible, and Air France has already compensated families. Investigators argued for dropping the case, but unusually, judges overruled them and sent the case to court.

Closing arguments set in Alex Jones' Sandy Hook trial

  Closing arguments set in Alex Jones' Sandy Hook trial WATERBURY, Conn. (AP) — A Connecticut jury is expected to hear closing arguments Thursday in a trial to determine how much Infowars host Alex Jones should pay for persuading his audience that the 2012 shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School was a hoax perpetrated to impose more gun control laws. The six-person jury could begin deliberations by the day's end in the lawsuit, one of several filed against the conspiracy theorist by relatives of the 26 people killed in the mass shooting.Since the trial began Sept.

“We made a promise to our loved ones to have the truth for them and to ensure that they didn’t die for nothing,” Ophelie Touillou, whose 27-year-old brother Nicolas was killed, told The Associated Press. “But we are also fighting for collective security, in fact, for all those who board an Airbus every day, or Air France, every day.”

Ophelie Toulliou, sister of a victim of the Rio-Paris plane crash, speaks during an interview with The Associated Press in Sannois, outside Paris, Friday, Oct. 7, 2022. It was the worst plane crash in Air France history, killing people of 33 nationalities and having lasting impact. It led to changes in air safety regulations, how pilots are trained and the use of airspeed sensors. (AP Photo/Christophe Ena): France Brazil Plane Crash © Provided by The Associated Press France Brazil Plane Crash

She said the companies present themselves as “untouchable,” and that Airbus made no effort to address families’ concerns. “For them, we are nothing. They did not lose 228 people. They lost a plane.”

Few families in Brazil, which lost 59 citizens in the crash, can afford to travel to France for the trial. Some feel the French justice system has been too soft on Airbus and Air France — two industrial giants in which the French government has an ownership stake.

The trial is expected to focus on two key factors: the icing over of external sensors called pitot tubes, and pilot error.

Kanye West accused of antisemitism over 'horrifying' Jared Kushner money-making comment and Sean 'Diddy' Combs Instagram post

  Kanye West accused of antisemitism over 'horrifying' Jared Kushner money-making comment and Sean 'Diddy' Combs Instagram post Two Jewish groups say Ye, AKA Kanye West, used antisemitic tropes when accusing Jared Kushner of trying to "make money" through the Abraham Accords.Chris Chester, whose wife Sarah and daughter Payton were also aboard the helicopter, was awarded $15 million after he and Bryant took on the county in a joint trial.

The Airbus A300-200 disappeared from radars over the Atlantic Ocean between Brazil and Senegal with 216 passengers and 12 crew members aboard. The first debris was only spotted at sea five days later. And it wasn’t until 2011 that the plane — and its black box recorders — were located on the ocean floor, in an unprecedented search effort at depths of more than 13,000 feet.

FILE - One of the two flight recorders of the Air France flight 447, that crashed in 2009, is displayed to reporters during a press conference at the French investigators' headquarters in Le Bourget, near Paris, May 12, 2011. It was the worst plane crash in Air France history, killing people of 33 nationalities and having lasting impact. It led to changes in air safety regulations, how pilots are trained and the use of airspeed sensors. (AP Photo/Michel Euler, File) © Provided by The Associated Press FILE - One of the two flight recorders of the Air France flight 447, that crashed in 2009, is displayed to reporters during a press conference at the French investigators' headquarters in Le Bourget, near Paris, May 12, 2011. It was the worst plane crash in Air France history, killing people of 33 nationalities and having lasting impact. It led to changes in air safety regulations, how pilots are trained and the use of airspeed sensors. (AP Photo/Michel Euler, File)

France’s air accident investigation agency BEA found that the accident involved a cascading series of events, with no single cause.

As a storm buffeted the plane, ice crystals present at high altitudes disabled the pitot tubes, blocking speed and altitude information. The autopilot disconnected.

Air France and Airbus face French court over Rio-Paris crash

  Air France and Airbus face French court over Rio-Paris crash AIRFRANCE-AIRBUS/TRIAL (PIX):Air France and Airbus face French court over Rio-Paris crashFlight 447 vanished in pitch darkness during an equatorial storm en route from Rio de Janeiro to Paris on June 1, 2009.

The crew resumed manual piloting, but with erroneous navigation data. The plane went into an aerodynamic stall, its nose pitched upward. And then it plunged.

The pilots ”did not understand what was happening to them. A difficulty of interpretation, in an all-digital aircraft like all the aircraft in the world today — well, it’s easy to be wrong,” said Gerard Feldzer, a former pilot and pilot trainer for Air France.

He said he and pilots around the world asked themselves afterward “if it had been me, would I have acted in the same way? It has been a very difficult question to answer.”

In this July 16, 2006 photo of Nicolas Touillou, who was killed in the 2009 Rio-Paris plane crash at age 27, poses for his fiance Gwenola Roger. It was the worst plane crash in Air France history, killing people of 33 nationalities and having lasting impact. It led to changes in air safety regulations, how pilots are trained and the use of airspeed sensors. (Gwenola Roger via AP) © Provided by The Associated Press In this July 16, 2006 photo of Nicolas Touillou, who was killed in the 2009 Rio-Paris plane crash at age 27, poses for his fiance Gwenola Roger. It was the worst plane crash in Air France history, killing people of 33 nationalities and having lasting impact. It led to changes in air safety regulations, how pilots are trained and the use of airspeed sensors. (Gwenola Roger via AP)

No one risks prison in this case; only the companies are on trial. Each faces potential fines of up to 225,000 euros — a fraction of their annual revenues — but they could suffer reputational damage if found criminally responsible.

Ophelie Toulliou, sister of a victim of the Rio-Paris plane crash, speaks during an interview with The Associated Press in Sannois, outside Paris, Friday, Oct. 7, 2022. It was the worst plane crash in Air France history, killing people of 33 nationalities and having lasting impact. It led to changes in air safety regulations, how pilots are trained and the use of airspeed sensors. (AP Photo/Christophe Ena): France Brazil Plane Crash © Provided by The Associated Press France Brazil Plane Crash

Nelson Marinho, whose son Nelson Jr was killed, is angry that no company executives will be tried.

Air Force crew performs first-ever rescue in brand new search-and-rescue helicopter

  Air Force crew performs first-ever rescue in brand new search-and-rescue helicopter Slaps roof of helicopter: 'This bad boy can fit so much rescue in it.'“The Jolly Green II is ready to get to work, and stands ready for the next rescue,” Moody Air Force Base wrote on its Facebook page on Saturday.

“They have changed various directors, both at Airbus and Air France, so who will they arrest? No one. There won’t be justice. That’s sadly the truth,” Marinho, a retired mechanic who leads a support group for victims' families, told The AP.

Air France is accused of not having implemented training in the event of icing of the pitot probes despite the risks.

In a statement, the company said it would demonstrate in court "that it has not committed a criminal fault at the origin of the accident” and plead for acquittal.

Air France has since changed its training manuals and simulations. It also provided compensation to families, who had to agree not to disclose the sums.

Airbus is accused of having known that the model of pitot tubes on Flight 447 was faulty, and not doing enough to urgently inform airlines and their crews about it and to ensure training to mitigate the resulting risk.

In this Oct. 29, 2006 photo of Nicolas Touillou, who was killed in the 2009 Rio-Paris plane crash at age 27, poses for his fiance Gwenola Roger. It was the worst plane crash in Air France history, killing people of 33 nationalities and having lasting impact. It led to changes in air safety regulations, how pilots are trained and the use of airspeed sensors. (Gwenola Roger via AP) © Provided by The Associated Press In this Oct. 29, 2006 photo of Nicolas Touillou, who was killed in the 2009 Rio-Paris plane crash at age 27, poses for his fiance Gwenola Roger. It was the worst plane crash in Air France history, killing people of 33 nationalities and having lasting impact. It led to changes in air safety regulations, how pilots are trained and the use of airspeed sensors. (Gwenola Roger via AP)

An AP investigation at the time found that Airbus had known since at least 2002 about problems with pitots, but failed to replace them until after the crash. The model in question — a Thales AA pitot — was subsequently banned and replaced.

Sandy Hook victims' families broke down in tears after a Connecticut jury ordered Alex Jones to pay them nearly $1 billion for spreading lies about the mass shooting

  Sandy Hook victims' families broke down in tears after a Connecticut jury ordered Alex Jones to pay them nearly $1 billion for spreading lies about the mass shooting As the verdict was read, Jones went live on Infowars, claiming he would not actually pay the families any of the money in damages. The Connecticut trial was the second of three similar cases Jones is facing. In August, a Texas jury ordered Jones to pay nearly $50 million to the parents of Sandy Hook victim Jesse Lewis. However, that award is likely to be slashed significantly due to a cap on punitive damages in Texas. Jones faces a third Sandy Hook trial back in Texas which has yet to be scheduled.

Ophelie Toulliou, sister of a victim of the Rio-Paris plane crash, speaks during an interview with The Associated Press in Sannois, outside Paris, Friday, Oct. 7, 2022. It was the worst plane crash in Air France history, killing people of 33 nationalities and having lasting impact. It led to changes in air safety regulations, how pilots are trained and the use of airspeed sensors. (AP Photo/Christophe Ena) © Provided by The Associated Press Ophelie Toulliou, sister of a victim of the Rio-Paris plane crash, speaks during an interview with The Associated Press in Sannois, outside Paris, Friday, Oct. 7, 2022. It was the worst plane crash in Air France history, killing people of 33 nationalities and having lasting impact. It led to changes in air safety regulations, how pilots are trained and the use of airspeed sensors. (AP Photo/Christophe Ena)

Airbus blames pilot error, and told investigators that icing over is a problem inherent to all such sensors.

“They knew and they did nothing,” said Danièle Lamy, president of an association of victims' families that pushed for a trial. “The pilots should never have found themselves in such a situation, they never understood the cause of the breakdown and the plane had become unpilotable."

FILE - Debris from the missing Air France flight 447 is put on display for the media after being recovered during search operations, at Recife's Air Force base, Brazil, June 12, 2009. It was the worst plane crash in Air France history, killing people of 33 nationalities and having lasting impact. It led to changes in air safety regulations, how pilots are trained and the use of airspeed sensors. (AP Photo/Roberto Candia, File) © Provided by The Associated Press FILE - Debris from the missing Air France flight 447 is put on display for the media after being recovered during search operations, at Recife's Air Force base, Brazil, June 12, 2009. It was the worst plane crash in Air France history, killing people of 33 nationalities and having lasting impact. It led to changes in air safety regulations, how pilots are trained and the use of airspeed sensors. (AP Photo/Roberto Candia, File)

Lamy lost her son Eric a few days before his 38th birthday. She has struggled ever since to find out the truth.

“The plane had sent messages to the ground about the problem but had not warned the pilots. It’s as if you were driving a car at 130 (kph, about 80 mph), your brakes were no longer working but the car sent the alert to the mechanic and not to the driver,” Lamy told the AP.

She is among 489 civil parties to the trial, which is scheduled to last through December.

The crash forced Airbus and Air France to be more transparent and reactive, Feldzer said, noting that the trial will be important for the aviation industry as well as for families.

FILE - Workers unload debris, belonging to the crashed Air France flight AF447, from the Brazilian Navy's Constitution Frigate in the port of Recife, northeast of Brazil, June 14, 2009. It was the worst plane crash in Air France history, killing people of 33 nationalities and having lasting impact. It led to changes in air safety regulations, how pilots are trained and the use of airspeed sensors. (AP Photo/Eraldo Peres, File) © Provided by The Associated Press FILE - Workers unload debris, belonging to the crashed Air France flight AF447, from the Brazilian Navy's Constitution Frigate in the port of Recife, northeast of Brazil, June 14, 2009. It was the worst plane crash in Air France history, killing people of 33 nationalities and having lasting impact. It led to changes in air safety regulations, how pilots are trained and the use of airspeed sensors. (AP Photo/Eraldo Peres, File)

“The history of aviation security is made from this, from accidents," Feldzer said.

___

Vaux-Montagny reported from Lyon, France. David Biller in Rio de Janeiro and Angela Charlton in Paris contributed.

Britain eyes new law to stop China from recruiting ex-military pilots for training .
British Armed Forces Minister James Heappey said the country "must change" a law to prevent former military officers from training Chinese pilots for battle. © Tyler Woodward/U.S. Air Force/UPI A Royal Air Force Typhoon receives fuel from a U.S. Air Force KC-10 Extender during a sortie in support of Combined Joint Task Force-Operation Inherent Resolve over Iraq, March 22, 2017. The British Defense Ministry warned ex-pilots this week about working for China. File Photo by Tyler Woodward/U.S.

See also