TOP News

World: Germany's ex-royal family win legal case against historian

How Princess Eugenie followed in Meghan Markle's footsteps after the birth of her son

  How Princess Eugenie followed in Meghan Markle's footsteps after the birth of her son Eugenie and her husband broke a major royal baby tradition followed by Kate Middleton and Princess Diana.Princess Eugenie and her husband Jack Brooksbank welcomed their first child, a baby boy, at The Portland Hospital in London on February 9.

By Madeline Chambers

a vase of flowers on a table: FILE PHOTO: Coffins are pictured inside the crypt of the Prussian emperors - the Hohenzollern house - during a media tour to present the restoration plans of the area in the Berlin cathedral in Berlin © Reuters/FABRIZIO BENSCH FILE PHOTO: Coffins are pictured inside the crypt of the Prussian emperors - the Hohenzollern house - during a media tour to present the restoration plans of the area in the Berlin cathedral in Berlin

BERLIN (Reuters) - A Berlin court ruled in favour of the heirs of the Prussian monarchy on Thursday in a dispute with a historian, the latest twist in a legal battle for compensation for treasures taken from the Hohenzollern dynasty after World War Two.

The family, which ruled Germany until Kaiser Wilhelm II abdicated in 1918, has demanded the return of thousands of paintings, sculptures and books from the German state as well as compensation for the expropriation of property by the Soviet Union whose forces occupied eastern Germany.

Germany tightens border checks to keep out virus variants

  Germany tightens border checks to keep out virus variants BERLIN (AP) — Germany on Sunday implemented tighter border controls on its frontiers with the Czech Republic and Austria’s Tyrol province in an effort to stem the spread of more contagious coronavirus variants. The new restrictions that took effect at midnight limit entry from those areas to German citizens and residents, truck drivers, transport and health service staff and a few others, who have to register online and show a negative coronavirus test. Interior Minister Horst Seehofer told the Bild am Sonntag newspaper that the new checks may cause some delays at the border and German police “will not just wave traffic through.

The question of the Hohenzollerns’ relationship with Hitler is central to the family’s claims. Under German law, compensation is only possible if the claimant did not significantly assist Nazis' rise to power.

Some historians argue the role of the Hohenzollern family was insignificant. Others say appearing with Hitler and his associates, including in a famous photo of Hitler with Crown Prince Wilhelm, eldest son of Wilhelm II, in Potsdam in 1933, was helpful and symbolic.

The family says on its website that two reports it commissioned have concluded that the family did not provide significant assistance to the Nazi regime. The family says this would back up their claim for compensation, but it also acknowledges that other reports come to a different conclusion.

Prince Philip Fast Facts

  Prince Philip Fast Facts View CNN's Fast Fact on Great Britain's Prince Philip (Duke of Edinburgh), husband of Queen Elizabeth II and the great-great grandchild of Queen Victoria.Here's a look at the life of Great Britain's Prince Philip, husband of Queen Elizabeth II.

a group of people in a room: FILE PHOTO: Visitors walk beside coffins inside the crypt of the Prussian emperors - the Hohenzollern house - during a media tour to present the restoration plans of the area in the Berlin cathedral in Berlin © Reuters/FABRIZIO BENSCH FILE PHOTO: Visitors walk beside coffins inside the crypt of the Prussian emperors - the Hohenzollern house - during a media tour to present the restoration plans of the area in the Berlin cathedral in Berlin

As part of a roughly 7-year wrangle with the states of Berlin and Brandenburg and the federal government, Georg Friedrich Ferdinand, Prince of Prussia, who is the great-great grandson of Wilhelm II, has taken legal action against dozens of historians and journalists.

The Berlin regional court upheld a preliminary injunction in a dispute about a statement made by historian Winfried Suess in 2019 as part of a debate about possible plans for a Hohenzollern museum in which returned artefacts would be displayed and whether the family would have a say in their presentation.

Critics say any such move could lead to revisionist interpretations of history.

"The defendant is still prohibited from making the statement that the plaintiff, as the head of an old German noble family, had demanded a say in the historic representation of the family in public institutions," the court said.

Suess told Spiegel Online after the decision: "If this legal opinion prevails, researchers will have a hard time talking about their work without legal assistance in future."

Germany's VHD historians' association condemned the ruling.

"This ruling could be momentous for academic freedom if statements by historians on the Hohenzollern compensation dispute about obvious facts can no longer be discussed publicly without legal action," VHD head Eva Schlotheuber told Reuters.

(Reporting by Madeline Chambers; Editing by Alison Williams)

Germany's Merkel warns of third wave if lockdown is lifted too quickly .
German Chancellor Angela Merkel has warned that her country could be caught in a third wave of Covid-19 if it lifts its lockdown too quickly. © Michael Kapperler/Pool/AFP/Getty Images German Chancellor Angela Merkel puts on her face mask after giving a press conference on the Covid-19 situation in Germany at the house of the Federal Press Conference (Bundespressekonferenz), on January 21, 2021 in Berlin.

See also